selected as an editors’ pick by food52

IMG_2929-Borscht500x358
I’m going to start counting to 5
As I reach 5, your face will fall gently away
Your eyes will pull in and relax
Your neck will sink down into your shoulders
Your body will slump
Your knees will fall out to the sides
Your hands crimped and tight will let go of all tension
1. . .2. . .3. . .4. . .5

Imagine you’ve awoken in a cabin before a window overlooking white fields and trees weighted down by snow. You’re wearing a vegan-friendly fur coat, muffs, and your honey has just come in from the cold and said, “Dr. Zhivago says hello.” You pounce.

After days of lovemaking and after reading Paglia and Sartre while soaking in a tub, you’re hungry for lunch. The most appropriate meal? Silky beet soup with a hearty hunk of black bread.

Oh, you say, you have just that warming up on the stove? Great, here’s how you got there.

not your everyday lower east side eastern european borscht

This is not the typical cabbage and beet peasant soup made with a heavy meat stock. This is a sultry and surprising beet soup (vegan when you don’t add the sour cream!) that is breathtakingly complex in its flavor profile, akin to the sweet, sour, tangy flavors of a Thai Pork Noodle soup enhanced with vinegar, sambal, and fried garlic.

I watched my Mother make this soup countless times since childhood and I think she made it with meat bones or meat stock, at the most, five times. Using meat stock subdues the amazing flavor of beets and imparts an oilier taste and texture, and also renders the soup less vibrantly burgundy and more orange red. No thank you.

What makes this soup such a standout is that the sweet beets coupled with the lemon juice create a nexus of sweet and tangy that you won’t experience in many other foods. If you were to leave the lemon juice out, the soup would be sweet, and still leagues more flavorful than the jarred impostor you’ll find in a grocery store. If a jar of sickly sweet beets in water is your only acquaintance with borscht, then I urge you to try this soup.

special guest star, juniper berry

I wanted to update this recipe without altering its original flavor profile. When you bite into a juniper berry, you’ll experience a softened berry bursting with small tart seeds. The berries have a sweet, earthy, and piney flavor that work perfectly with the fresh dill and the tang of the soup.

dr. zhivago silky beet soup

makes 8 servings

10 cups of water
1-2 tbsp grapeseed oil
1 large onion, finely chopped
1 bay leaf
3 medium beets (or 2 large, 1 small)
2-3 carrots, (2 large or 3 small to medium ones)
1 large potato, cubed (use a waxy potato like yukon or red)
1 celery, cut into thin moons
1/4 bunch fresh dill, minced
1/2-1 whole lemon, juice of
2-3 tsp of salt
dash of freshly ground pepper
12 juniper berries, optional, but highly recommended*
1-2 cloves of garlic, optional, but highly recommended
1 tbsp of sour cream per bowl, optional (people who are generally averse to sour cream, may like it in this unusual combination)

Set your pot of water on low heat. Add in 1 tbsp of oil, chopped onion, bay leaf and juniper berries. Peel the beets and cut them into halves if they’re small enough or into thirds or quarters if they’re very large. You want them to be of relatively equal size. Drop them gently into the water as you continue working on the rest of the vegetables. You might be tempted to start seasoning the soup here or adding salt to flavor the vegetables as they cook, but in order to get the full flavor, sweetness, and color out of the beets, you need to salt this after you grate the beets. Beets, like sweet peas and some other vegetables, will “seize up” if you salt them too early.

Peel and cut the carrots into rounds, and for the potatoes, cut them into 1/2″ size cubes or small chunks. (I prefer my vegetables small as I find they distribute a lot better into individual bowls.) Add in the chopped celery and the juice of 1/2 of a fresh lemon. Bring your heat up and cook the soup until a fork easily pierces through one of the larger beet pieces; this should take about 15 minutes on medium low heat.

While the beets are getting tender, you should skim the soup from some of the foam that will form. By doing this, you will inevitably be taking out some of the oil along with it. Once you’ve skimmed it, put in an additional 1/2 tablespoon of oil.

IMG_2885and2889-BorschtPrep500x167
Once your beets are done, scoop them out of the soup (bringing back into the pot any vegetables that might have clung to the beet) and let the beets cool for 2 minutes so you can handle them more easily. At this point, you can turn the pot to low heat. I’d advise wearing gloves for the next part so you don’t have to take beet stains off your hands. Using the large holes on your grater, shred your beets. Once you’ve grated all the chunks, carefully put all the shredded beets back into the soup pot and let this cook for an additional 10 minutes.

The soup should have a sweet tart taste. After the 10 minutes, add in the dill and taste the soup to adjust flavors accordingly. Add your salt now, a tad of pepper, and if the soup is still too sweet for you, another tablespoon or 2 of fresh lemon juice and a tad more salt. Remember that if your soup is very hot, you will not taste the actual level of salt, so err on the side of less, as each time you reheat the soup, it will get slightly saltier. This soup gets better and better in the following days.

notes

Serve hot or cold, with sour cream or not, but eat this with black bread. If you want to make the soup a bit spicier, add thin slices of garlic to the soup just before serving. If you want just a hint of garlic, then rub a cut clove over the crust of your bread. (You should do this whenever you want, not just when eating borscht!)

In the Winter, if you want to experience an even more authentic Russian meal, serve this soup with a side of mashed potatoes topped with sardines. Let the juices of the sardines drip into the butter- or milk-mashed potatoes.

If you cook this in the Summertime, omit cooking with juniper berries and use a topping of cubed persian cucumbers or a hard boiled egg split in half.

*If you are diabetic, have kidney problems, or are pregnant, please consult with your doctor before using culinary dried juniper berries.

IMG_2933-BorschtExtra500x407

Related posts:
  1. chestnut madeira soup
  2. truffle oil optional
print, share, and bookmark this recipe
| More

{ 1 trackback }

Beets, phase 2 | Ari Cooks
December 12, 2010 at 12:59 pm

{ 11 comments… read them below or add one }

lo February 12, 2010 at 1:39 pm

Although I usually make my beet borscht with a meat-based stock, the flavors in this recipe look amazing. I’m particularly attracted to the juniper berries, which are a fairly recent new love of mine.

the naked beet February 12, 2010 at 1:46 pm

Lo, thanks for stopping by. Yes, juniper berries are a recent favorite of mine, too and I’m looking forward to posting more recipes with them (a Tuscan boar ragu in a few weeks).

Alan S. Finkelstein February 17, 2010 at 3:48 pm

This looks amazing and I can’t wait to try it.
For an old school eastern European rooted Jewish kid like me who likes to cook, I have only made it once. I love beets and borscht.
However, I made my last one when the teal iMac 1st came out and it included a Williams-Sonoma CD-ROM that had a Borscht recipe. I have never been able to find the recipe because the iMac is long gone and the CD only runs on very very old software. It was made w/ beef consomme amongst other things and had orange juice and a shot of vodka in there. I brought to my Russian raised neighbor friend who told me it was the best borscht she ever had :)
Where the heck do you get juniper berries?
thx for the posting.-al

the naked beet February 21, 2010 at 8:34 pm

Alan, your William Sonoma recipe sounds fantastic (vodka, orange juice, and meat stock?) I’ll have to try and hunt down the recipe or I might just have to improvise and create another version. You can get juniper berries in an Italian market or a quality spice store. I’ve updated the ingredient list with one possible source for juniper berries.

Aron March 28, 2010 at 8:42 pm

That sounds fantastic!

the naked beet March 28, 2010 at 11:09 pm

Aron, thanks for visiting the site, I hope you find more to enjoy and try.

Rob July 28, 2010 at 6:14 am

I love borscht and beets. They roast so well. Here is our ode to them. http://tinyurl.com/22m7vnr

Hannah March 8, 2012 at 12:38 pm

This is AMAZING!! as a jewish-american twenty-something living in south america, i get intense cravings for eastern european foods and simply have to find the way to make them myself. This recipe, it is really the perfect light borscht, and I’m especially jazzed to finally dip into my jar of juniper berries that i’ve been saving for just such an occasion.
my only modifications: I grated the beets while raw and salted at the end of cooking as recommended, used the juice of two limes, and substitute fresh sprigs of flowering thyme for the dill. I ate a huge bowl for dinner, warm, with a dollop of greek goat milk yogurt swirled in. PERFECT!! I can’t wait to eat the leftovers and then make it again and again. Thank you, thank you!!

Ross September 4, 2012 at 7:02 pm

Do you have a good recipe for Black Bread?

the naked beet September 14, 2012 at 11:13 am

Ross, that is definitely on my to do list as the weather gets colder. There are 2 recipes I’m looking to compare further, but if you make one of them, please report back! One is Smitten Kitchen’s, another is from the book, Ancient Grains for Modern Meals by Maria Speck (this is a much simpler recipe and needs fewer ingredients). I find her recipe intriguing because she calls for pumpernickel flour, molasses, whole rye berries and a slow rise and bake.

the naked beet September 14, 2012 at 11:15 am

So glad you enjoyed this! The greek milk goat yogurt sounds amazing, I’ll have to look for this in our Greek markets.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: